The Smart Forecaster

Pursuing best practices in demand planning,

forecasting and inventory optimization

In order to reap the efficiency benefits of forecasting, you need the most accurate forecasts—forecasts built on the most appropriate historical data. Most discussions of this issue tend to focus on the merits of using demand vs. shipment history—and I’ll comment on this later. But first, let’s talk about the use of net vs. gross data.

Net vs. Gross History

Many planners are inclined to use net sales data to create their forecasts. Systems that track sales capture transactions as they occur and aggregate results into weekly or monthly periodic totals. In some cases, sales records account for returned purchases as negative sales and compute a net total. These net figures, which often mask real sales patterns, are fed into the forecasting system. The historical data used actually presents a false sense of what the customer wanted, and when they wanted it. This will carry forward into the forecast, with less than optimal results.

Suppose your sales data is aggregated into monthly totals. If monthly net figures are used, and returns occur in the same month that they are purchased, no problem. The net activity for the month reflects actual demand. But what if the product is returned three or four months after it was purchased, as often occurs? The net figures are underestimate interest in the product for the month when the return is counted, and (it would seem) overestimate demand for the month of the initial sale. Reflecting product demand at the wrong time in this way interferes with the forecasting system’s ability to properly identify the pattern (or lack thereof) in the data.

Since you fill orders you as you get them, you are hardly going to decline to ship because you think they might return the product in a few months. Customers wouldn’t stand for that. So of course you want to know that such demand is likely to occur. If the orders are going to come, you need stock in your inventory to meet the demand, regardless of later returns. Using net figures is not the best practice in these situations.

In most cases, data used in preparing forecasts needs to be based on gross figures. Returns can be forecast as a separate variable and used as a source of incoming supply. This will result in fewer unnecessary orders of new inventory. Ultimately, this approach better captures the true patterns in the data—the heart of forecasting.

Shipment vs. Demand Data

A second important distinction regarding historical data may seem counter-intuitive. Forecasters are nearly always encouraged to use demand data because it is assumed to better reflect what the customer wanted and when. However, when you have the choice, it can sometimes be smarter to use shipment data.

One guiding principle is to consider the accuracy of the data. In most businesses, the shipment data accurately reflects exactly what was shipped, while the demand data is often plagued with inaccuracies. Here are a few examples:

Customers may know, for example, that you will be unable to fill their order. In that case, they may refrain from placing the order, holding off until they believe you have stock on hand to meet their needs. On the other hand, anxious customers may file multiple electronic orders, concerned that some miscommunication could prevent a vital order from being processed. When assured that one order has been accepted, they may cancel the additional orders. Then there is the case of a customer that has experienced stockouts with you in the past. They may increase the size of their orders to maximize the chance that inventory will be allocated to them.

If such practices plague your order history, it may be more prudent to use shipping data. You can then use SmartForecasts’ “adjust history” feature to fine tune the shipment data—so it better reflects demand. You can certainly do the same on inaccurate demand data but often this will require much more effort than simply correcting for obvious cases where shipments are low one month and high the next due to a stock-out situation.

Before making a decision on whether to use shipment or demand data, it is important to understand how orders and returns are accounted for in your system. Talk to your customer service reps and ask them about how they would account for these situations. Don’t take your IT department’s word for it. Exercise your judgment to get the best results.

Making the right data choices will go a long way toward achieving valuable supply chain efficiencies. Take the time to read Michael Gilliland’s post on this topic at the Institute of Business Forecasting and Planning’s blog, at demand-planning.com.

Gregory Hartunian serves as President of Smart Software and as a member of the Board of Directors. He previously held the position of Vice President of Sales.

Leave a Comment

Related Posts

Daily Demand Scenarios

Daily Demand Scenarios

In this Videoblog, we will explain how time series forecasting has emerged as a pivotal tool, particularly at the daily level, which Smart Software has been pioneering since its inception over forty years ago. The evolution of business practices from annual to more refined temporal increments like monthly and now daily data analysis illustrates a significant shift in operational strategies.

Learning from Inventory Models

Learning from Inventory Models

In this video blog, the spotlight is on a critical aspect of inventory management: the analysis and interpretation of inventory data. The focus is specifically on a dataset from a public transit agency detailing spare parts for buses.

The Methods of Forecasting

The Methods of Forecasting

Demand planning and statistical forecasting software play a pivotal role in effective business management by incorporating features that significantly enhance forecasting accuracy. One key aspect involves the utilization of smoothing-based or extrapolative models, enabling businesses to quickly make predictions based solely on historical data. This foundation rooted in past performance is crucial for understanding trends and patterns, especially in variables like sales or product demand. Forecasting software goes beyond mere data analysis by allowing the blending of professional judgment with statistical forecasts, recognizing that forecasting is not a one-size-fits-all process. This flexibility enables businesses to incorporate human insights and industry knowledge into the forecasting model, ensuring a more nuanced and accurate prediction.

Recent Posts

  • Overcoming Uncertainty with Service and Inventory Optimization TechnologyOvercoming Uncertainty with Service and Inventory Optimization Technology
    In this blog, we will discuss today's fast-paced and unpredictable market and the constant challenges businesses face in managing their inventory and service levels efficiently. The main subject of this discussion, rooted in the concept of "Probabilistic Inventory Optimization," focuses on how modern technology can be leveraged to achieve optimal service and inventory targets amidst uncertainty. This approach not only addresses traditional inventory management issues but also offers a strategic edge in navigating the complexities of demand fluctuations and supply chain disruptions. […]
  • Daily Demand Scenarios Smart 2Daily Demand Scenarios
    In this Videoblog, we will explain how time series forecasting has emerged as a pivotal tool, particularly at the daily level, which Smart Software has been pioneering since its inception over forty years ago. The evolution of business practices from annual to more refined temporal increments like monthly and now daily data analysis illustrates a significant shift in operational strategies. […]
  • The Cost of Doing nothing with your inventory Planning SystemsThe Cost of Spreadsheet Planning
    Companies that depend on spreadsheets for demand planning, forecasting, and inventory management are often constrained by the spreadsheet’s inherent limitations. This post examines the drawbacks of traditional inventory management approaches caused by spreadsheets and their associated costs, contrasting these with the significant benefits gained from embracing state-of-the-art planning technologies. […]
  • Learning from Inventory Models Software AILearning from Inventory Models
    In this video blog, the spotlight is on a critical aspect of inventory management: the analysis and interpretation of inventory data. The focus is specifically on a dataset from a public transit agency detailing spare parts for buses. […]
  • The methods of forecasting SoftwareThe Methods of Forecasting
    Demand planning and statistical forecasting software play a pivotal role in effective business management by incorporating features that significantly enhance forecasting accuracy. One key aspect involves the utilization of smoothing-based or extrapolative models, enabling businesses to quickly make predictions based solely on historical data. This foundation rooted in past performance is crucial for understanding trends and patterns, especially in variables like sales or product demand. Forecasting software goes beyond mere data analysis by allowing the blending of professional judgment with statistical forecasts, recognizing that forecasting is not a one-size-fits-all process. This flexibility enables businesses to incorporate human insights and industry knowledge into the forecasting model, ensuring a more nuanced and accurate prediction. […]

    Inventory Optimization for Manufacturers, Distributors, and MRO

    • Why MRO Businesses Need Add-on Service Parts Planning & Inventory SoftwareWhy MRO Businesses Need Add-on Service Parts Planning & Inventory Software
      MRO organizations exist in a wide range of industries, including public transit, electrical utilities, wastewater, hydro power, aviation, and mining. To get their work done, MRO professionals use Enterprise Asset Management (EAM) and Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems. These systems are designed to do a lot of jobs. Given their features, cost, and extensive implementation requirements, there is an assumption that EAM and ERP systems can do it all. In this post, we summarize the need for add-on software that addresses specialized analytics for inventory optimization, forecasting, and service parts planning. […]
    • Spare-parts-demand-forecasting-a-different-perspective-for-planning-service-partsThe Forecast Matters, but Maybe Not the Way You Think
      True or false: The forecast doesn't matter to spare parts inventory management. At first glance, this statement seems obviously false. After all, forecasts are crucial for planning stock levels, right? It depends on what you mean by a “forecast”. If you mean an old-school single-number forecast (“demand for item CX218b will be 3 units next week and 6 units the week after”), then no. If you broaden the meaning of forecast to include a probability distribution taking account of uncertainties in both demand and supply, then yes. […]
    • Whyt MRO Businesses Should Care about Excess InventoryWhy MRO Businesses Should Care About Excess Inventory
      Do MRO companies genuinely prioritize reducing excess spare parts inventory? From an organizational standpoint, our experience suggests not necessarily. Boardroom discussions typically revolve around expanding fleets, acquiring new customers, meeting service level agreements (SLAs), modernizing infrastructure, and maximizing uptime. In industries where assets supported by spare parts cost hundreds of millions or generate significant revenue (e.g., mining or oil & gas), the value of the inventory just doesn’t raise any eyebrows, and organizations tend to overlook massive amounts of excessive inventory. […]
    • Top Differences between Inventory Planning for Finished Goods and for MRO and Spare PartsTop Differences Between Inventory Planning for Finished Goods and for MRO and Spare Parts
      In today’s competitive business landscape, companies are constantly seeking ways to improve their operational efficiency and drive increased revenue. Optimizing service parts management is an often-overlooked aspect that can have a significant financial impact. Companies can improve overall efficiency and generate significant financial returns by effectively managing spare parts inventory. This article will explore the economic implications of optimized service parts management and how investing in Inventory Optimization and Demand Planning Software can provide a competitive advantage. […]